Already a member?
Sign in
Location: Dexter: The Books vs. The Series
Discussion: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter...
Watch
|
nall nall |
This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter...
Dec 17 2007, 6:38 AM EST This whole comparison is skewed and was obviously done by someone in charge of the shows marketing. Still it's kind of a let down that they would go so far as to insult and belittle Jeff Linsday. Personally i found the books to be an excellent read and with many more turns in the storyline to keep me interested. This article is way off though, whoever wrote it bashes the author for taking 'cheesy' plot twists, then a few lines down he bashes him for being too bland and not doing enough with the story. 15 out of 22 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
ZizzyB23 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Dec 17 2007, 12:20 PM EST Wow, what article is this and who do I have to punch in the face? (Just kidding I won't punch anyone, but seriously, what article is this?). I really liked the books and really liked the show. Can't I like them both? In some aspects, I like the show more, and in others, the novels, but I wouldn't call any of them bad. 7 out of 9 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
nall nall |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Dec 21 2007, 3:35 AM EST there's a page on the dexter wiki that compares the books and show...very few of the comparisons were fair until i adjusted a few things...still some of them are off... 0 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Alaskawolf |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Feb 2 2008, 2:25 PM EST I'm just glad I wasn't the only one who didn't like that little comparison. Honesty? Who can say "the show did it better?" The books were the originals, and I like them much more than the show. The little "twists" and add-on's don't make it better, they make it different. They didn't fix Dexter, or Brian, or anything else, they simply changed them to suit their own needs. The show's interesting and all, but really, I only liked it because it was an outlet for my Dexter addiction. To say the show did it better is not any different than saying "the fanfiction did it better." 2 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
dexgal |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Feb 2 2008, 10:05 PM EST "I'm just glad I wasn't the only one who didn't like that little comparison. Honesty? Who can say "the show did it better?" The books were the originals, and I like them much more than the show. The little "twists" and add-on's don't make it better, they make it different. They didn't fix Dexter, or Brian, or anything else, they simply changed them to suit their own needs. The show's interesting and all, but really, I only liked it because it was an outlet for my Dexter addiction. To say the show did it better is not any different than saying "the fanfiction did it better.""Well, I like to think of the show as the writers' way of using their collective imaginations to let the characters in Lindsay's come to life for them. I do the same thing with characters in books myself--I see them looking and acting and interacting in a certain way. It's wondeful that we can all do the same thing. I really enjoy the books, but I think the creators of the show and the actors and writers do a fabulous job of integrating the print characters with visual imagination, and let us experience them all in as many modalities as possible. I think that we all my somewhat skew elements in life to fit out own realities; perhaps we do the same for our fantasies...anyhow, it's like comparing apples and oranges! 3 out of 4 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
bluebutterfly1234 bluebutterfly1234 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Feb 8 2008, 12:35 AM EST In my opinion the show is much better than the books, but the books are still an interesting read (the first one mainly)... but nothing can surpass the show. I think the way they handled Ice Truck in Season One was brilliant compared to the books. I didn't like book three at all because of what they did with the Dark Passenger. And the books never addressed what happened to Brian, unless I somehow missed it. And that was disappointing! 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
mdcoolbaugh |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Mar 7 2008, 7:31 PM EST Why do people feel the need to compare the books and the show? Thats like trying to compare the Resident Evil games to the movies. There are going to be major differences because some things just work better in a book than onscreen. I like the fact that they are different so that you have the opportunity to like them both for what they are. 2 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
dexgal |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Mar 8 2008, 11:11 PM EST "Why do people feel the need to compare the books and the show? Thats like trying to compare the Resident Evil games to the movies. There are going to be major differences because some things just work better in a book than onscreen. I like the fact that they are different so that you have the opportunity to like them both for what they are."yes, it would be really difficult to complete compare the Resident Evil games to the movie...lol! 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
2Blaze 2Blaze |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Apr 12 2008, 12:01 AM EDT The books are better and I am hoping that Jeff comes out with another novel. I have read all three books and I am sometimes baffle and upsett because they change some of the best parts in the books. I do understand that the series have to make changes from the book. I do love the books and if you know that if Jeff is writing another Dexter book, please let me know. thanks blaze 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
lunalovesdexter |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter...
Apr 19 2008, 6:10 PM EDT Yes, do people not realize,if it were not for the books,and for Mr. Lindsay, there would be no tv show? I find the books are more intellectually stimulating, and very different at times from the show, but I will take the images from my imagination over the boob tube any day! 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jwnelson11 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Apr 21 2008, 11:02 PM EDT "Why do people feel the need to compare the books and the show? Thats like trying to compare the Resident Evil games to the movies. There are going to be major differences because some things just work better in a book than onscreen. I like the fact that they are different so that you have the opportunity to like them both for what they are."I do agree with you on this one. I will not talk bad about either one as they are there for good reasons. If the book did not exist then we may not have Dexter to talk about. The biggest problem I have is that when people get on this wiki, and say the book this and the book that. I do not care what the book sez. I do not plan to read them at this point in time mainly because I have too many other books to read, and be cause I really like Dexter as it is in my mind now. I do not want to change the images and the memories of this. I do not want Cody to become a serial killer, and I really like the character development as it is now. I have read too many books / that movies were made from and was so disapointed in the Hollywood version that it ruined the whole thing for me. So I will never read the books and I will keep copies of the show, or buy copies of the series. What ever I need to do, and watch it as I remember it. Although, I can see my self, one day going (I will do anything once) or saying to myself, I need a Dexter fix, and in a moment of weakness order the books a read them after all. It's not that I am wishy washy, but like I said I will do anything once, or more like I am open minded. Any way I do prefer the series TV media, rather than the book at this point in time. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jwnelson11 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter.
Apr 21 2008, 11:09 PM EDT I just read my posting and wanted to add, that I do not or can not say the series is better of course I do not know. But I do know that what we have left in our minds after we read is sometimes better that what we have watched. The shows are the result of what a Producer, Director and Script writer have done to the book by thier minds eye. Then the actor can also change the mood of the show. Sorry this was wasted space I can see now. I appreciate anyone who has read it. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
sharksmile |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 23 2008, 8:46 AM EDT The show is hypersexualised like any other TV show nowadays, I'm not saying it's bad of course, but the book didn't contain many of the sexual scenes they stuffed in the series, and they made dexter a bit sexual although he doesn't see any joy in these degrading , human acts as the book showed. 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jwnelson11 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 24 2008, 1:41 PM EDT "The show is hypersexualised like any other TV show nowadays, I'm not saying it's bad of course, but the book didn't contain many of the sexual scenes they stuffed in the series, and they made dexter a bit sexual although he doesn't see any joy in these degrading , human acts as the book showed."Yeah ! Dont get me started on this. I really do feel this is a bad thing. I think our children are getting the wrong message. There is too much of this on TV and I really feel strongly that it gives our kids a message. The Wrong message. I think it plants ideas/things in thier minds. Then they want to experience what they have watched. So yeah the hypersexuality as you call it is very real and is played to often. I think adults can diferentiate it, but the young ones I mean under 14 yo can not. There are too many stories in the news about kids doing things they should not even know about at that age. Sorry !1! I just stepped down off my soap box. I dont like what Bush did to our America also, But a different Soap Box. ( Sorry I guess I got it all out of my system) LOL 0 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
sharksmile |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 24 2008, 5:50 PM EDT ^^I still think the show is hypersexualised because that's want people want to see, and that's not true to the real dexter. but i mean you're right, not only kids get the Wrong Message but also full grown up men, and women, sex on TV makes some people want to sleep with their pets and molest their kids. Do you think Obama will fix all that mess? mmm... 2 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
ZizzyB23 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 24 2008, 6:14 PM EDT "^^I still think the show is hypersexualised because that's want people want to see, and that's not true to the real dexter.Alright, let me preface this by saying I hate the sex in the show. Its ridiculous, it seems forced, and I just don't like it at all. Its not true to Dexter at all. That being said, the show is about a man who KILLS PEOPLE FOR FUN. I'm not worried about kids getting the wrong idea about sex on a show like this. In fact, this show isn't intended for children anyway. Perhaps parent's should do more parenting and worry about what their kids watch on tv instead of letting the government do it. And I think sex on tv does give people the wrong idea of what its like (believe me, sex isn't half as fun or exciting as it looks on tv), but I don't think it makes people want to molest their kids or pets. I've seen a lot of sex on tv, and have never wanted to do either of those things. People who do are just inclined to do that crap anyway, and don't need a tv to tell them what to do. So as you can see, I'm really anti-censorship, and feel people need to control what their kids do. However, like I said I wish there wasn't any crazy sex in the show (season one had two sex scenes, thats fine. Season two had multiple ones. Not fine). I just don't want it there because I feel it makes the show seem more cheesy and Hollywood than it should (and since I pay for a Showtime subscription, I think this is a demand I can make), and not because it gives the youth of America the wrong idea about sex. 2 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
sharksmile |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 24 2008, 6:43 PM EDT I agree that nobody in their right mind should let their kids watch dexter. I'm only pissed because every TV show or movie makes every rat fart seem related to sex . It's a shame that the producers of dexter are doing that more often to attract audience, which is no more than greed and lack of originality. Not freedom of art, just brick-headed greed. 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jwnelson11 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 25 2008, 2:04 PM EDT "^^I still think the show is hypersexualised because that's want people want to see, and that's not true to the real dexter.Obama may be saying all of the correct things. But what I am seeing on my TV is a completely different mess. I am not a racist in any way but I am seeing a lot of reverse racism comments from the black community. It seems to me that if there is a black prez. then it will cause all sorts of internal problems meaning we will be riating in our own streets we will not be sending troops to Bagdad for war it will be in the USA. I am worried that the really racist on both sides of the color line will be butting heads. If you dont believe me then just watch the news after he has had a press confrence. It is the news media that is pushing all of the buttons, and asking all of the wrong questions. I really do no care what color or sex my prez is as long as they are fair to all, and do not have poeple that they owe. Bush has spent all of time in office as a meat puppet for the oil company and doing what he thought his Daddy wanted to finish when he was in office. Bush has done nothing for my socio economic group except screw it to the desk. It is sort of funny that with Clinton - He screwed any thing he could get away with at arms length. Bush has screwed the whole country. ( There is not doubt that Bush spells it cuntry ). Sorry you should not have mentioned politics. 0 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jwnelson11 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 25 2008, 2:16 PM EDT "Alright, let me preface this by saying I hate the sex in the show. Its ridiculous, it seems forced, and I just don't like it at all. Its not true to Dexter at all.But having something like sex so prevalant on a media that you can watch so easy as the TV. It can desenstize you to what it really is. It makes it seem like that is what eveyone does ect. I have seen children interviewed I mean grade school kids talk about having sex as though they were talking about getting a glass of juice. Lts face it. When TV was first in most of the homes in the USA, they would not allow a man and a woman in the same bed on the air, This is why all of the black and white shows have two beds in the bed room and at one time only one person was in it at a time. Then there was the hell, and damn, and ass controversy. They would not allow any of those words said on TV as it was immoral. Now of course the F+&k work. It was never said in the movies as it was a vulgar word. Now it is so common place it makes me sick. It is a vulgar word. and we have been desensitzed to it. It is so common now days it is not considered a vulgar word it is accepted. I do think TV has this ability to plant subliminally messages that things we should not think to be common place to be accepted. TV is a cheap baby sitter. Yes parents should parent. But they put the kids in a room and turn on the TV so they can watch what ever they wnat to. Parents should wATCH What the kids watch. They do not. Kids get desensitized to all of it. That is the truth. 2 out of 4 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jwnelson11 |
RE: This is a terrible injustice to the author and creator of Dexter..
Apr 25 2008, 2:20 PM EDT "Alright, let me preface this by saying I hate the sex in the show. Its ridiculous, it seems forced, and I just don't like it at all. Its not true to Dexter at all.I do agree about the sex it is not necassary. I have beena proponant of the CBS version as it is cleaned up, and a lot of the crap is taken out. But I have also noticed that Dexter has been cleaned up also, meaning it seems like his killing is taken down a notch or two, It seems that the reality of Dexter being a Sociopath/Psychopath has been dropped down a little. We all know about it cuz we have seen the Showtime version, and know what he is. But the new viewer may not get it. 4 out of 6 found this valuable. Do you? |

