Location: Episode 12: "The British Invasion"

Discussion: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obviously).Reported This is a featured thread

Showing 21 - 31 of 31  |  Show  posts at a time
Previous | 1 2

Enderdejorand
21. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvio
Dec 25 2007, 12:06 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 25 2007, 12:06 AM EST
I don't know, alot about the series has made me think, "where else can they go with this?" Dexter is BY FAR one of my favorite TV shows, but a lot of times it seems like the execution of things is a little too neat or predictable. Season 1, "O, Dexter's a sociopath cus he saw his mom's murder. Trauma = sociopath, we get it!" Season 2, "Crazy wild card Lila and disturbed CoWorker? EZ FIX! *dead*" Even look at the season finale, a big part of the episode was him redoing the episode introduction slightly differently... I know he liked his newfound freedom, but I think we can all admit that was filler in a big way. They could've just as easily inserted a bunch of witty phrases Dexter says to himself while some more plot is developed, assuming they had it... (maybe address the deb/lundy thing, or insert Angel again?)

Basically, this leads me to wonder where Season 3 is going to go. Season 1 had another killer, so that's probly out. Season 2 had him almost being caught, so again, nix that. The 2nd book has Dexter begin to train Cody as a killer, so could that be in the future? Also how is LaGuerta going to tie into all of this? If you ask me, she seems like a loose cannon, herself. Doakes' death -and- public humiliation seems to have made her more than a little unstable.

I just don't want Dexter to become one of those shows that goes on, just because it can. Hopefully they won't decide to make up random plots that don't fit the characters, but how many 'natural' storylines can really be explored here? Already I thought Lila was cutting it close, same with Doakes' imprisonment. And the suicide of Harry? that seemed really out of place. The need a way to clean up the Harry sideplots so it doesn't seem like they are just pulling them out of their asses... make it seem more realistic. *Best hopes for the show, we can't let it die out!*
2  out of 2 found this valuable. Do you?    
ZizzyB23
ZizzyB23
22. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvio
Dec 25 2007, 1:28 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 25 2007, 1:28 AM EST
"I don't know, alot about the series has made me think, "where else can they go with this?" Dexter is BY FAR one of my favorite TV shows, but a lot of times it seems like the execution of things is a little too neat or predictable. Season 1, "O, Dexter's a sociopath cus he saw his mom's murder. Trauma = sociopath, we get it!" Season 2, "Crazy wild card Lila and disturbed CoWorker? EZ FIX! *dead*" Even look at the season finale, a big part of the episode was him redoing the episode introduction slightly differently... I know he liked his newfound freedom, but I think we can all admit that was filler in a big way. They could've just as easily inserted a bunch of witty phrases Dexter says to himself while some more plot is developed, assuming they had it... (maybe address the deb/lundy thing, or insert Angel again?)

Basically, this leads me to wonder where Season 3 is going to go. Season 1 had another killer, so that's probly out. Season 2 had him almost being caught, so again, nix that. The 2nd book has Dexter begin to train Cody as a killer, so could that be in the future? Also how is LaGuerta going to tie into all of this? If you ask me, she seems like a loose cannon, herself. Doakes' death -and- public humiliation seems to have made her more than a little unstable.

I just don't want Dexter to become one of those shows that goes on, just because it can. Hopefully they won't decide to make up random plots that don't fit the characters, but how many 'natural' storylines can really be explored here? Already I thought Lila was cutting it close, same with Doakes' imprisonment. And the suicide of Harry? that seemed really out of place. The need a way to clean up the Harry sideplots so it doesn't seem like they are just pulling them out of their asses... make it seem more realistic. *Best hopes for the show, we can't let it die out!*"
Man, I've had all these concerns myself. I guess in the end of the day, we just have to trust the writers and producers to let out a quality product. I think its entirely possible to have another season with another serial killer, only if its done really well, and the killer doesn't end up being somebody close to Dexter and co. (that'd be too much like season one. It'd need to just be some dude).
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
dexgal
dexgal
23. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvio
Dec 25 2007, 8:29 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 25 2007, 8:29 PM EST
"Man, I've had all these concerns myself. I guess in the end of the day, we just have to trust the writers and producers to let out a quality product. I think its entirely possible to have another season with another serial killer, only if its done really well, and the killer doesn't end up being somebody close to Dexter and co. (that'd be too much like season one. It'd need to just be some dude)."
...or dudette...
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
ZizzyB23
ZizzyB23
24. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvio
Dec 26 2007, 1:48 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 26 2007, 1:48 AM EST
"...or dudette..."
lol. Or dudette. Your right. The writers need to consider themselves equal opportunity employers when it comes to serial killers.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
dexgal
dexgal
25. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvio
Dec 26 2007, 9:52 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 26 2007, 9:52 AM EST
"lol. Or dudette. Your right. The writers need to consider themselves equal opportunity employers when it comes to serial killers."
Well, both kinds are grown in Florida...
Do you find this valuable?    
ARayne
ARayne
26. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvio
Dec 26 2007, 10:22 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 26 2007, 10:22 AM EST
"It felt unfinished to me - unsatisfying. Those two had such intense chemistry - they could have made it a great scene. I think they wimped out. There were some dark places they could have taken it and they got scared. "
Okay so after the official week has past of the finale and the unofficial release have past these 3 weeks, I have to voice this one more time..... I HATED the finale. I've come to realise that there absolutely NO good moments, except when Deb fixed Lundy's tie, that was just plain cute.
Why I hated the finale..... It, like Morgaine has used the phrases before, was unsatisfying. Okay, by now everyone knows I am the biggest or the 2nd biggest fan here (it's a tiebreaker between me and dexgal at the moment, noone is competing here though) of the Deb/Lundy show, but as some have mentioned, it feels like the door has been left WIDE open for Lundy's return next season....

The finale had too many loose ends. Was Dexter planning on killing Lila at her place? Is that why he showed up there? And then when Deb arrived before Lila did, that was supposed to give Deb a HINT whe he grabbed her from behind, but no Deb didn't question that any further. Then Lila arrives, takes Dex's bag... Too many loose ends with Dex and Deb there.
Very disappointed, totally unsatisfied and I really, completely and utterly HATED the finale... Totally. Doubts anyone?
0  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
ZizzyB23
ZizzyB23
27. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvio
Dec 26 2007, 1:53 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 26 2007, 1:53 PM EST
You know, I sort of had a reverse reaction to the final. As time has passed, I think its sort of grown on me. Everything I've said in this post I still stick to completely (I blinked, and suddenly Lila was dead! What the-) but I think I've learned to accept it I guess. I think a problem we all have is that season one was just so damn good, and there is almost no possible way they could top it. We should accept the finale for what it is (I guess). I don't know... as I type I keep getting more and more depressed about the finale. Why'd you have to die Doakes!? And Dex, Lila deserved to suffer! Thanks ARayne! 1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
Kaliline
Kaliline
28. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obviously).
Dec 28 2007, 3:40 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 28 2007, 3:40 AM EST
"That is a very good way to put it. I however wouldn't have wanted the Lila thing carried over to season three. I think the writers are trying to start fresh next season. I'm glad she died, but the scene could've been more dramatic and satisfying to me."
I actually found this to be a very satisfactory ending. To me it seems that Dexter saw this as "taking out the trash" and was just cleaning up. He saw the Lila character for what she was, and didn't give it anymore emotion or energy than necessary. I think that's the reason the writers moved that part of the story along quickly - so as not to give it more of our attention than what it deserves. What we focus on is that Dexter not only survives but starts to come alive and into his own.
BTW - What great writing, and acting, with this Lila character!
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
dumpLilaNOW
dumpLilaNOW
29. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvious
Jan 1 2008, 12:31 PM EST | Post edited: Jan 1 2008, 12:31 PM EST
I started reading the new book (Dexter in the dark) and Doakes is still alive.....but he has lost his arms & legs and his tongue. So I dont know how that happened but Dex and Rita are getting Hitched. Do you find this valuable?    
ZizzyB23
ZizzyB23
30. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvious
Jan 1 2008, 4:27 PM EST | Post edited: Jan 1 2008, 4:27 PM EST
"I started reading the new book (Dexter in the dark) and Doakes is still alive.....but he has lost his arms & legs and his tongue. So I dont know how that happened but Dex and Rita are getting Hitched."
You do know that season two is NOT a representation of the second book right? And even Season one is different from the first book in some ways (ie: LaGuerta is dead).
0  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
RicemanDan
RicemanDan
31. RE: I was just a tiny bit disappointed by the finale (SPOILERS obvious
Aug 2 2009, 4:40 PM EDT | Post edited: Aug 2 2009, 4:40 PM EDT
I think the finale was rushed, with loose ends, but I have no real complaints. Lundy/Debs could easily be omitted - as someone said, it will sure to be reformed in season 3 (I know, I know, it's Aug 09 and I'm not started on season 3 yet :p). Batista was settled too - what's to see after the hug/exchange/gratitude with Debs? I also liked the quick death with Lila - she deserved nothing more. I think her addition (sorry to the actress - I'm a Brit too) was a really bad appointment for season 2 and if a much stronger actor/character could have taken that role, the season could have been a lot better (same goes for Debs, for the entirety of Dexter!).

I loved Dex's imaginary scenes of telling Debs he's the butcher - haha! The last one with the shot to the head was brilliant - muchos credit again to Mr Hall!

Zizzy. The Wire and Dexter cannot be compared - both are great shows, but the wire is a totally different animal - raw, gritty, realistic and edgy. Dexter is a supremely fictional fantasy and a look into the world of the unkown. The Wire is the complete opposite - we look deep into the world of the well known, through many facets and faces. The 2 shows could not really be more different, so I think you should realise this and give the Wire your full attention. I was like you, not wanting to bow to everyones praise, but I could not help how good it is....

Season 2 (Dex) was good - perhaps too much going on for my liking - sometimes it nice to digest and have more filler scenes. I much preferred season 1, like yourself, though Doakes really came into his own in 2, which I was pleased about. Season 1, he was a let down and too simple.

Lots of flaws throughout - I mean, Dexter planning the route to the cabin via a sat nav, in his car, whilst the feds are raiding the city and their own department??? Really not in the Dexter mould - the writers "used" it for their wrap up ending.
Do you find this valuable?    
Previous | 1 2